QLD Comment Bank
QLD Report Card Comments: Science
QLD report card comments for Science: science understanding, inquiry and human endeavour examples, with A–E wording for Years 3–10 and next steps.
This page is a practical summary of publicly available guidance. Always follow your school's reporting template and professional judgement.
Quick compliance checklist
- Comments reflect the Australian Curriculum (ACiQ) Science achievement standard for the year level.
- The comment names the unit or investigation the grade is based on.
- The wording matches the scale for the year level: A–E for Years 3–10, the descriptive scale for Years 1–2, the five-point Prep scale for Prep.
- Describe what the student can do with evidence, then give one specific next step.
- Keep the comment to about 70–100 words and in plain English parents can follow.
What a QLD Science comment should cover
Queensland teaches Science from the Australian Curriculum (ACiQ v9), which has three strands: science understanding, science as a human endeavour and science inquiry. A report card comment rarely needs all three. Choose the strand your assessment this semester gave you the best evidence for, which is usually the unit’s investigation or assessment task.
- Science understanding: the concept the student can explain, such as forces, life cycles, the water cycle or chemical change.
- Science inquiry: questioning, predicting, planning a fair test, recording and analysing data, and evaluating results.
- Science as a human endeavour: how people use science knowledge, including Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples’ knowledge of the environment.
- Future learning: one concept or inquiry skill to work on in the next unit.
Primary Science comment examples (Years 1–6)
Examples
- "[Student] explained how the shape of a boat affects whether it floats, using the results of our class investigation as evidence. They made a prediction before testing and changed only one thing each time. Next steps include recording measurements in a table so patterns are easier to see."
- "[Student] described what plants need to grow, drawing on the bean seeds we observed over four weeks. Their observation diary was detailed and carefully labelled. Next steps include explaining why some seeds grew faster than others."
- "[Student] identifies the stages in the life cycle of a frog and compares them with a butterfly’s. With prompting, they use science words such as tadpole and metamorphosis. Next steps include using these words independently when explaining their thinking."
- "[Student] is beginning to make simple observations using their senses and shares them with the group. With teacher support, they record what they notice in drawings. Next steps include saying what they think will happen before an experiment starts."
Secondary Science comment examples (Years 7–10)
Examples
- "[Student] planned a valid investigation into the effect of temperature on reaction rate, identifying the independent, dependent and controlled variables. Their discussion linked the results to particle theory. Next steps include evaluating the reliability of their data and suggesting improvements to the method."
- "[Student] explains how energy moves through a food web and predicts the effect of removing a species. Their research assignment drew on credible sources. Next steps include using data from the case study to support each claim."
- "[Student] carried out the practical safely and recorded their results accurately. Their conclusion described what happened but did not yet explain why. Next steps include linking each result back to the scientific concept from the unit."
Science as a human endeavour examples
Examples
- "[Student] researched how a local Aboriginal community reads seasonal signs to guide fishing and harvesting, and connected this to our unit on weather. Next steps include comparing this knowledge with Bureau of Meteorology data."
- "[Student] described how scientists test and review ideas before they are accepted, using the development of a vaccine as an example. Next steps include explaining how new evidence can change scientific understanding."
Matching Science wording to the A–E grade (Years 3–10)
- A (Very High Achievement): "evaluates", "justifies with data", "designs and refines investigations independently".
- B (High Achievement): "explains clearly", "plans a fair test", "draws conclusions from evidence".
- C (Sound Achievement): "describes", "follows a method", "identifies patterns in familiar contexts".
- D (Limited Achievement): "with support", "is developing the ability to", "records some observations".
- E (Very Limited Achievement): "is beginning to", "with significant support", "identifies simple features".
Tips
- Years 1–2 use the descriptive scale and Prep uses the five-point Prep scale, so adjust the wording for those years.
- Name the investigation or unit so families know what the grade is based on.
- Enthusiasm for practical work is worth mentioning, but the grade reflects the achievement standard.
Official sources
Create a QLD-aligned comment draft
Use QLD School Reports to draft a comment, then edit it to match your evidence and school template.
Related links
- Generate Science report card comments — Draft QLD-aligned Science comments from your notes on each student.
- Pricing — Token packs for drafting QLD report card comments.
- Features — How the comment generator works and what it covers.
- Queensland achievement scales and reporting — Prep, Years 1–2 and A–E scales explained.
Explore the QLD reporting cluster
QLD Report Card Comments: HASS
QLD report card comments for HASS, History and Geography: sources, maps, civics and inquiry skills, with A–E examples and next steps to adapt.
QLD Report Card Comments: A–E Levels
QLD report card comment examples for each A–E level, from Very High to Very Limited Achievement, plus the wording that separates one grade from the next.
QLD Report Card Comments: Mathematics
QLD report card comments for Mathematics across Number, Algebra, Measurement, Space, Statistics and Probability, with A–E examples and clear next steps.
